October 1, 2026
As Monterey County Now reported, a three-bedroom home on Sunset Lane in Pebble Beach was booked most weekends this past fall, listed at more than $1,300 a night. When the home was booked, Monterey County had not issued it a permit to operate as a commercial vacation rental, and Pebble Beach Company had not given its consent. The county approved the home's application on August 13, 2026, but as of late August the home continued to operate without the company's road-access consent.
This reflects an unresolved question about short-term rental regulation in Del Monte Forest, and it affects how buyers weighing rental income should evaluate a county permit.
Monterey County's coastal vacation rental ordinance took effect on October 24, 2025, and it sets out vacation-rental rules for Del Monte Forest. On paper, that puts Pebble Beach in a different category from Big Sur, Carmel Highlands, and Carmel Valley's residential zones. Monterey County Now reported that commercial short-term rentals are banned outright in those areas by the same ordinance.
As Monterey County Now reported, the company's general counsel, Diane Goldman, told the county:
"The plain meaning of the CC&R language bans short-term vacation rentals in the Del Monte Forest."
That position has not moved since the company issued its blanket objection in 2024, shortly after the Board of Supervisors first adopted the ordinance.
On August 13, 2026, the county's Zoning Administrator heard four vacation rental applications for Pebble Beach properties, including a second home on Sunset Lane, and approved all four. Those approvals do not resolve the separate road-access question.
Pebble Beach Company continues to withhold road-access consent for those same addresses. Joseph Sennish, chief financial officer of Carmel Coast Estates, which manages the Sunset Lane rental, has taken the opposite legal position from the company, arguing that the recorded CC&Rs actually do give owners and their guests permission to use the roads. Neither side has backed down. District 5 Supervisor Kate Daniels, whose district includes Pebble Beach, asked for a continuance on one of the appeals, saying she wanted to understand the CC&R and private road issues before the board sets a pattern that plays out property by property. That matter was rescheduled to August 25, 2026, and more appeals on other Pebble Beach rental applications are expected to follow the same path.
For a buyer evaluating a listing today, the practical upshot is this: a Zoning Administrator's stamp tells you the county thinks a given rental clears county rules. It tells you nothing about whether Pebble Beach Company, which owns the street the house sits on, agrees.
The same county ordinance governs several unincorporated Monterey County communities, but it does not treat them the same way once you look past the permit categories.
| Area | Commercial Vacation Rentals | What actually blocks them |
|---|---|---|
| Del Monte Forest / Pebble Beach | A cap near 4%, according to the Monterey County Vacation Rental Alliance | Pebble Beach Company has not provided private-road consent |
| Carmel Highlands | Banned outright by ordinance | The ban itself |
| Big Sur coast | Banned outright, consistent with the Big Sur Coast Land Use Plan | The Land Use Plan has never recognized short-term rentals as a principal residential use |
| Carmel Valley | Banned within residential districts | The zoning designation itself |
The listed areas have different rules. In Del Monte Forest, Pebble Beach Company has not provided private-road consent. The road-access question remains unresolved and is being considered property by property.
A county permit number in a rent roll may appear to establish approval, but it does not establish that private-road consent is in place. If a Pebble Beach property's income projection assumes short-term rental revenue, the county permit addresses one part of the question; private-road access is a separate issue.
Before you count rental income into a Pebble Beach purchase, get specific answers rather than general assurances:
A buyer's own diligence should not stop at "does the county allow it."
Is this likely to resolve soon? The Monterey County Vacation Rental Alliance has an active tolling agreement with the county and the Coastal Commission from October 2025, and filed an additional suit in August 2026 challenging the Coastal Commission's certification of the coastal ordinance. Multiple Pebble Beach permit appeals are also pending before the Board of Supervisors. Treat the current rules as the operative ones for now, and confirm the status again before relying on them in an offer.
Does the same issue apply in Carmel Highlands or Big Sur? No. In those areas commercial vacation rentals are banned by the ordinance itself. The complication described here is specific to Del Monte Forest's private road ownership.
If you are weighing a Pebble Beach purchase and want the current answer for a specific address rather than a general one, Alex Brant can help you get it in writing before you write the offer.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Homeowners Insurance, Independent Brokers, California FAIR Plan Coverage and What Buyers Need to Know
Monthly Report
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact Alex today to discuss all your real estate needs!